REVIEW FORM WITH REVIEW CRITERIA FOR AN iNEER PAPER:

i. Contents (e.g.: clarity of objectives; basis of theory; conclusions drawn; understanding of subject; etc.):

ii. Degree of Novelty or Originality (e.g.: presence of new ideas; innovative contributions; whether bulk of materials has been published elsewhere; etc.):

iii. Structure of Paper (e.g.: general layout; use and proper numbering of figures/diagrams; etc.)

iv. Quality of Text (e.g.: clarity of expression; consistency; readability; number of quotations and references; etc.):

v. Reviewer’s General Opinion and Comments (e.g.: correctness of text; applicability of the items included; quality of paper; scope covered; etc.):

vi. Reviewer’s Summary Recommendation (Please mark “X” on only one item below):

____ Accept Paper

____ Accept Paper if Revised According to Suggestions Given in “Reviewer’s Comments” Above

____ Reject Paper for Reasons Given in “Reviewer’s Comments” Above